Breaking Down First and Second Degree Burglary Charges in California

Consideration was given for the editing and publication of this post.

According to the California Penal Code 459 the act of burglary involves breaking and entering a property in order to commit theft or felony. This could refer to an apartment or another place of residence, a business office, a cargo container and even storage units and tents.

However, California law recognizes two degrees of burglary. But what constitutes a first degree burglary or second degree burglary? This depends on several factors, including the type of property you entered and the type of theft committed: petty or grand.

In this article, we break down the difference between first and second degree burglary.

First Degree Burglary

The first degree burglary involves breaking into a place of residence or dwelling, like a house or an apartment. This type of burglary usually involves a harsher sentence than a second degree burglary.

A person facing first degree burglary charges can be sentenced by two, four or up to six years in prison. Since this type of burglary marks a strike on a criminal record, a convict has to serve 85% of their sentence.

However, if they were convicted with a prior strike, they will have to serve a double sentence and at least 80% of this sentence. Finally, if this is the third strike on your criminal record they are facing 25 to life.

Second Degree Burglary

Second Degree burglary involves breaking into a structure that does not serve as a dwelling, like an office with the intent to commit theft or felony.

Since this type of burglary is considered a wobbler, the prosecution can choose to treat it whether as a felony or a misdemeanor. The prosecutor’s choice depends on a number of factors.

If the burglary is filed as a felony, a convict could face a sentence of three years maximum. If it is filed as a misdemeanor, a convict is looking at a sentence of up to 364 days.

The factors that help determine how to file a second degree burglary involve whether a person charged has any prior convictions, what type of crime they committed upon breaking and entering and whether there’s enough evidence to convict them.

Naturally, a grand theft will lead to a larger sentence. You can read more about what constitutes a grand theft here: https://www.monderlaw.com/pratice-areas/theft/grand-theft

What are the Possible Defenses?

The prosecution has to present the evidence proving that the accused intended to commit a crime upon breaking and entering for both types of burglary charges. Therefore, there are several possible defenses against the allegations.

  • The defense could try to prove that the defendant was not aware of the party’s intent to commit a crime upon burglary.
  • The defendant did not commit an act of burglary, leading to a false accusation
  • The defendant did not intend to commit a crime
  • The defendant was intoxicated and couldn’t form intent.
  • The defendant was invited by an owner or a resident of the structure
  • The police violated the defendant’s constitutional rights.

If you are accused of burglary in San Diego, contact Monder Law Group at 424 F Street, San Diego, CA, US; 619-405-0063.

November 6, 2017 · Editorial Team · Comments Closed
Posted in: News